Abstract: 

Dynamic Traffic Assignment (DTA) is long recognized as a key component for network planning and transport policy evaluations as well as for real-time traffic operation and management. How traffic is encapsulated in a DTA model has important implications on the accuracy and fidelity of the model results. This study compares and contrasts the properties of DTA modelled with point queues versus those with physical queues, and discusses their implications. One important finding is that with the more accurate physical queue paradigm, under certain congested conditions, solutions for the commonly adopted dynamic user optimal (DUO) route choice principle just do not exist. To provide some initial thinking to accommodate this finding, this study introduces the tolerance-based DUO principle. This paper also discusses its solution existence and uniqueness, develops a solution heuristic, and demonstrates its properties through numerical examples. Finally, we conclude by presenting some prospective future research directions.